Titan Q3: Writing
How did you feel about Varley as a writer? Did his style appeal to you? Annoy you? Leave you indifferent? What was he best at? What should he not have bothered attempting?
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
How did you feel about Varley as a writer? Did his style appeal to you? Annoy you? Leave you indifferent? What was he best at? What should he not have bothered attempting?
Comments
I'm not a good one for picking up on writing, turns of phrase, and that sort if thing. That said, I think the writing here was serviceable if a little dull.
It didn't annoy me - I think he's a very serviceable and engaging writer. But neither did I ever find a passage so nice I was moved to jot it down - which I did with the other books by Boorman and Cooper that I read this month. The writing here was thriller-like and it kept me engaged - it was a page-turner, as they say. I like that Varley tackles women and gender fluidity. I'm not sure I was all that convinced by Gene's sociopathic behaviour, but it was hand-waivable given the circumstances. (I don't mean Gene' behavior was excusable - I mean Varley's treatment of it was excusable.) Unlike Neil, I never found the book dull.
Agreed - his writing was competent and fluent, but not exciting or memorable. The most interesting departure from some SF was the conscious and creative inclusion of Greek mythology into the mix. I didn't find it dull, and was never at any risk of giving up, but equally I wasn't especially drawn to read other books by him - my impression is that they'd be interesting rather than anything more.
I did feel (without of course having read the next two books in the series) that it could have been a stand-alone volume, and felt that the fairly sudden switch into setting up the next volume jarred a bit. I'd have been happy for the book / series to end with a bit more about the arrival of and interaction with the second Earth ship and less "don't miss next week's exciting episode".
Agreed with @Apocryphal that for its time the variation in sex and gender was unusual and innovative.